About the Flour Substitute Converter
All-purpose flour sits in the middle of a spectrum of protein content, with bread flour above it and cake flour below, and that protein level directly controls how much gluten a dough or batter develops.
How It Works
Enter an amount of all-purpose flour, and the calculator returns equivalent amounts for bread flour, cake flour, and self-rising flour, including the leavening and salt additions self-rising flour requires.
Examples
Making a self-rising flour substitute
2 cups of all-purpose flour converts to 2 cups plus 3 teaspoons of baking powder and 0.5 teaspoon of salt for a self-rising flour equivalent.
Approximating cake flour
2 cups of all-purpose flour converts to about 2.2 cups scaled cake flour, or alternatively, 2 cups minus 4 tablespoons of all-purpose with 4 tablespoons of cornstarch sifted in.
Advantages
- Covers three common flour substitutions from a single all-purpose flour amount
- Includes the leavening and salt additions needed for a self-rising flour equivalent
- Notes the cornstarch-swap method as an alternative to the scaled cake flour figure
Common Mistakes
- Using self-rising flour in a recipe that also separately calls for baking powder and salt, resulting in over-leavened, over-salted results
- Substituting bread flour for cake flour (or vice versa) without expecting a real texture difference
- Not sifting the cornstarch-and-flour cake flour substitute together thoroughly, leaving pockets of unmixed cornstarch
Edge Cases to Watch For
- Bread flour's higher protein content builds more gluten than all-purpose, giving chewier bread but potentially tougher cookies or cakes if swapped in without adjustment.
- Cake flour's lower protein content produces a more tender crumb; the cornstarch substitution method, replacing 2 tablespoons per cup with cornstarch, approximates this without needing to buy cake flour specially.
- Self-rising flour already contains leavening and salt, so any recipe using it should drop separately listed baking powder and salt to avoid doubling up.
Common Use Cases
- Making a cake flour or self-rising flour substitute without buying a specialty bag
- Understanding the texture tradeoff when substituting bread flour for all-purpose
- Converting a recipe's flour type when only one kind is on hand